# Shein's Ethics Score Outranks Several Australian Retailers in New Report

> The 2026 Baptist World Aid Ethical Fashion Report assigned fast-fashion giant Shein a higher ethics score than several established Australian brands that declined to provide assessment information.

By PrimaryBrief newsroom · Published 2026-10-24T06:49:35.508669Z
Canonical: https://primarybrief.com/article/shein-s-ethics-score-outranks-several-australian-retailers-in-new-report-182697c9

The 11th Baptist World Aid Ethical Fashion Report, released in October 2026, gave fast-fashion brand Shein an ethics score of 28 out of 100 [9][11][12]. This score, while below the overall industry average of 31.5, surpassed several established Australian retailers such as Ghanda and Windsor Smith, both of which scored zero [1][9][11][12]. Shein's higher score was partly attributed to its cooperation in providing information for the assessment [11][12][14][16].

This finding matters to consumers who increasingly consider ethical and environmental impacts in their purchasing decisions. It challenges common perceptions of fast fashion brands versus traditional retailers, showing transparency can affect assessment outcomes. The report reveals a broader stagnation in ethical progress and persistent issues within global fashion supply chains.

## What the records show

The 2026 Ethical Fashion Report, compiled by Baptist World Aid Australia, evaluated 138 companies representing 543 brands across five supply chain topics, including worker protection and environmental sustainability [3][7][11][12][14][18]. The average score for all companies was 31.5 out of 100 [7][9]. Shein's score of 28 placed it above Australian companies like Myer, which scored 20, Seafolly with 1, and Boardriders, which scored 3 [11][12]. Ghanda and Windsor Smith received scores of zero [1][11][16]. Many Australian brands, including Myer, Seafolly, Ghanda, Windsor Smith, and Boardriders, did not supply extra information and were assessed solely on publicly available data [11][12][16]. Companies that did not participate in the research project were assessed only on their publicly available information, which tends to yield a lower ranking [11][16]. Shein, however, supplied additional information for its assessment [11][12][14][16].

## The report's findings

Ethical progress within the fashion industry has largely stagnated, with the average score improving by only 0.2 points since 2024 [7][9][11]. Critical issues persist: 87% of companies failed to provide evidence of living wages in their supply chains [7][9]. Only 9% demonstrated union representation or collective bargaining in most final-stage facilities [7]. Half of the assessed companies had no targets for reducing supply chain emissions [7]. While the use of sustainable fibers increased from 30 percent to 38 percent over two years, this was offset by a rise in overall fiber production, particularly petroleum-based synthetics [7]. Australia holds the distinction of being the world's highest consumer of textiles per person [3][6][11]. The data collected for this report covered the period from 2024 to 2026 [9]. In 2024, Australia surpassed the United States as the world's biggest consumer of clothing [4][5][6].

## What we could not confirm

We could not confirm the specific reasons why certain Australian retailers declined to provide additional information to Baptist World Aid for their assessment. The detailed nature of the additional information provided by Shein and how it specifically contributed to its score remains unelaborated in the provided evidence.

## Evidence cited
1. Ghanda and Windsor Smith are among lowest-rated in Baptist World Aid ethical fashion report based on metrics such as wages and sustainability. — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQETZhIjuyZs4jU4qe2RQUvx1xOCYJJXn1wI77n6wuUJrqMZ34NV4SbXvzYjSEEhv_ZJfA9vLrKq1w9w6964Lh9FKKOZZyhd321UhJcHcFO_dqvk_HniWobpBBHrBuKwkgpVTv0J0qfrW8NN
2. Ghanda and Windsor Smith are among lowest-rated in Baptist World Aid ethical fashion report based on metrics such as wages and sustainability Get our ... — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQG4EUkh-2ocToDlXJLFfl88EjqvkquwOcJIvmuzPR7RCDsUj32jNOwUzz8wWXpLAb9dAo1VLA8_UsG2GDfxH7eOwNT-_Sa0F41vKrVY6csUQdqv6OxIX0LEal-aJA8YH2dJZxluN8ZB
3. FAQs | Ethical Fashion Report | Baptist World Aid Australia (baptistworldaid.org.au) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFju61_A8zkx2HSvevBTzbs-j1XrPHmQPvuApW8Fw36rZOQ_x2h8rEZ_EzGVv6VJb-iIZpNXbvfmvFv8g7qkt-mt8aZSVwybTSNH27U15JyLIdgsHcQO_fu9LkbLy4pRhzKqnW0394Sr0niQrdyL9qj1GBHHKHpwlDLO6s=
4. Ethical Fashion Report 2024 - Tasmanian Baptists (tasbaptists.org.au) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGZbv_lxNv2yTVmPzXd22270BcAvyh2j00xJFLRSIAAbYStxDdK0ir30PeGALuhwl7YxeEVBfaYTKG7h-RLCdyDxA3mHvnsFYasp5xuop8qlWrZbukyvL5Sf4d4ZQ3ZsUU0fxNpg_aWtqGZ9GqfDLgJgk3Q
5. Australia leads global fashion consumption: 10th Ethical Fashion Report - Fibre2Fashion (fibre2fashion.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEp779XslD_w1oIgOggrD9kaxLzdOtA_7Cj2XspQpXiexzLay_VJCrt8tOsLEz1qOPdla-90XT0Xif-ixQvtAp89MdbhKjBZi8zz59SRsxolVn27S8eSg4R4uAS3x39a-auNCBI4rMc0PX3KHuKW14HQgf9CHNJ-GDxPqRmQ7I5hrhx4Bjh_DesTbAykroP4PmyxymNdyuO4D04R7wLDBvVTfYnQ7cJES9tUdVYSGKWiuexb92FeSsdvW47j8M=
6. Australians buy more clothes than any other country - The Australia Institute (australiainstitute.org.au) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGqwfgse-w4q31fQn_uHehzxURFLHnEzBuHgrPZr3k3WxQNUGWDGKqZ9_UATY_oFt7GGCnzXBUKsVa6fKwTvUzLbzAvVkNCZ5r_SerZjgq_ShBtlaSX4bVkbvmYqBsgi6d-NqPd-2ghL9Wv2MgEYJnz8Tymny6i1N6TaJEms5J5iK4-FArizeiLVGYF4GlaIRtkqupcDZAbKYGP3Ng18U7MIhzHNR_0GRKDa_KL2-AuRw==
7. Baptist report highlights gap between fashion brands' commitments and workers' rights (christiandaily.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEC1S9hkBGZ4cvlv0xPBFxgZydabqtIKX7oJmlrZgSAWwo26Xof7PYtyOYdU3VL1OkFzGZuZolOC9FqiF4DueTF8uQDqqTgrGM-wgHBTa5gsjNX6rY15Q6BuKZTX3rDC3bzppZRy-uR-cXSIDkISlwuGS-YstCnkGcMXEyJSC-mD6wIFdH9qPISJd4ZDinAwDJlGax9Y_o5cr2BgQJuoDCe-E2_jqT09MtVlDuGTWNQPw8=
8. About the Report | Ethical Fashion Report | Baptist World Aid Australia (baptistworldaid.org.au) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFkWD2MxDhvkatoR2hy76t5iqOyUuFmg1np_v_ANtoB4fDEfUpSyK2zg-LxgVnBvjaE0t2j_KbKgPHdLcKR63vaoqPIYdjLEw-XImnRz8Wrgfd7_5hGopBf_E8BLHku3OaC9gDZj4oIRV9QlQWuQ_cm0duAdlPJHjkDzvMCATdiFmQEuTeT0vVIftaK
9. 2026 Baptist World Aid Ethical Fashion Report reveals stagnant industry progress (youtube.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEIhyDUKS8TrvA9l958NId7whir4_wESbUu-dBg22AbmgOzuG-U2_VzuY5NtnZDVCFRiE9MSz0d_kHB0yySn3UI5PCRhQvMWyYgZ6xaZuP4ivU0Ub723Mc_vE4CZk718w00Aq38
10. Australian fashion ethical practices stalling, Baptist World Aid report finds — Kyna Intel (kyna-intel.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGHCifI_rSQKqJ7V7eN9trxB1MCDvPDZsngyffuTHeQAmXDNqZRokblSQIGBXtdKoQF4B0fejSh4wePk_aUlBKEBgCsN5Wv6dogYRXRMBKhQcN1uLQ4nBZ-fgtgc3ZggfBa70Rk_omPbTV4
11. Fast-fashion giant Shein outperforms several Australian retailers on ethics, report says | Fashion industry | The Guardian (theguardian.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHTfNgN7NizPSStdhZNpZPr6abdQ2YIs9uOE9IVdkgMmJZfFdQ9C0cWTewh_bi0FKY0mszYWhRGFcEx3cUvEAd6upf4hIy6QHNvDSuGBBkV8hqiADZqFI2wlgn4O_OTwVzHh8vBTY3csq71fhH2Zxgm1iB-DNphLNJAqyrRg_H3guiWxUN7uhSWSr3HH1_LFH9UAKJlYfFuoyGfGuagH8EGx1a1pMSoLGbI9ixgCSCB_xRo4_53
12. Shein Scores Higher Than Myer in Ethical Fashion Report: What It Means for Consumers - Shade Compass (shadecompass.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQH0FyS3XhKc6v3zWZcSONYRud09zNnwo8vrgsFA6xK-YWVSTwNEZvCR2GrxQwjsrbOIDpBwbHxyJXBo-XdPvElx6ye3Jj5-FMjZjaiuwLRNciecmuoL7vSGSAvFOsgzNIMFDojEFSSgc82Q4RmZdURw
13. 2024 Ethical Fashion Report reveals Temu and SHEIN fall short in addressing labour issues - Business and Human Rights Centre (business-humanrights.org) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEGnpriv8o9smbQFuaWmHsC63TcPlp9WB3E-xPFmXHm1T_S_yWyPgs60dKIMIk0TWM10k88JqvNxyo5doOhlVrJ0wNsI6PskVyjW6f3VQFPBgmV7i8pG28m--1n_U7quw7FkgtO31BqPKchdgzH_5u3JM4T_JWRwBq5m3a_ZJntdAhBigX5lAxOXoN7JmevU_TzdRLh3m8eXOWG8S3eY4LR--fCmSalI3Ch3GU39STlaKcznITX6pJid7H6jlrO-YeNehNr8hAorGQ=
14. Shein tops Myer, Boardriders in Baptist World Aid’s ethical fashion report (drooid.social) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFjxLaimcKxCDEcvswrjL_lHqA-4Yb8Cc9LXZ5UR7xcILdTA4hzJa9YkfwzKMa9YuZVRrm5qSdTHv7mBx0_m9daT0giT6f1n0RBIolejn0kvzgAe-gdH48nD2xkdRI--RqblJDBAuLZ2oe8f-snEbFLpOzV_6Ev7NvO3KAWMwZO-trZnahaN3X8D6eDMaNzXM6XPdwCIzEINV0u
15. Shein Scores 28 in Ethical Fashion Report, Rises | Drooid (drooid.social) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEay3ghvTLqxK3JgKfq0Q4ZmZg1xoWMwf1NZ1AwAq61xqHQ-22nIJtXz9nN4wHNtTyE-yhTgulZb_YYNAdYU9za0BkLtBOlrsjKcAjvvnYC0X0wp3XW6s5bTdxnbQhXsgyEJ1tKZ0aDWvQXGqWDiU2857LM-JE9YZAx6w9WDyYB2q3V3opyjwvXjrP4
16. Shein beats many Aussie retailers on ethical standards - Mediaweek (mediaweek.com.au) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGxXqXC_5VZz_Vt-LH5BggFUiekqk5PsFs54VjT-lUIiJhtnJRnIyGevrtgoX-jSOm1Cni8RNWG023uqMw_D9D_yp3Yr_A22Hl1zGxHzOgj9sO7iwvlD2xw50Rz9mLw_3255gUfQroDal_b9O37WOxq4Dc2sDxBwyZeCtsdozdQYdwzeLSQAI4=
17. Baptist World Aid Ethical Fashion Report, 11th Edition — Kyna Intel (kyna-intel.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGRKIAs67l4f3QNYG1Cq_3y2pHJ8M56G_1HunkFda5V4W0YkrSOEUlJjGrqxa3t17wuFi3gpnKzk0uEmEWeW_POEZcM9NXvHahJqkr9du8JvU-tgTl4Pudj8yW4pedqkG9PygWvfYBs5fq0
18. Fashion’s ethical progress stalls, says report (ecotextile.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFGeeOgCNBIOqO-bGsajj8SdwbSxumXGH_T62A9D1sMd4nOmSXly3OTchm21YEZOdcJCg05W0A9Vs-Djrs-X0lvcICjYS_J5GOhhdu4OWeq9owEBakT_fnn32y9O_XDipU_vA8nXek9rcemEQ0QJZdEIdS95k4yElUeXFb0DjrtHRlZqQEDeuukNDtw52fkb-9THz7XU0AfV55cvuTOC8sn1g-81JLNu8WlWAvF_t3n
19. Nine out of 10 fashion companies fail to show they pay living wages: report | Sight Magazine (sightmagazine.com.au) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEw75IjR6vTy-93IEjmoKt1Rz4VDbmy-xLnPNthUinYSVBmJYkIMnV7K8obKh_kHz4o6mmbqx2GujLZ-Aec3RvdVVLMY2sXXoJxNaz6ef37c_mqR1ashJ8gIyUo9uJPA0jhf8CWKkRSWftxA1TRM8G6YN6C-B8wfKggzGeaCB366b_RUhEIbW6VCyHIs1epRSI_Vu-eGeSpkbL6bpw_J07a6B0HtUf8LyP0e37_em8sHeSZLy-5v40_F47zYSCVB3sBeW6Uc-kp7npFIjvQDWpv
20. Baptist World Aid Report: Fashion Brands Fail to Meet Living Wage Commitments (gospeller.org) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQH3Xi0EcueJJ8ffJVHWdzeaafxvZqj5oJor2a77Y6UtTPLuMScIfwbxap0QhsDJJAfuh16NP26Lg7C3acMhoFydeNqQVHTTAjFXc4Ki80x1J_DlABkQDTRdYLEddCWWDoT9KQSbwZUVnL4zBKU_Nct0IoZ_NQXRHBTol_fNXUuwJHQ3-t_JAg9MMFniawX_xKqfFi_WELQgI0kpcj9XACjtvk2yQq8m
21. 87% of Fashion Companies Fail to Verify Living Wages in New Report (primarybrief.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHG_CKhxXZwDbccXeqS5MDZ1A0VQKmcoZVYEKAi6_yPfdC9FAfCYloCRhaCxyP-IghyrtnGVA0AkE73GflE58Fd8eBmSVjwwV3UvOe0LLgsgUSH06XHUJJFVpZhX58MGXPahVFwoYJ1SeVS44XygFXsTX7kJsOYx_d-f3eP9U2i7pRQsx-DjWE61y2ex_5sG5-2g9KpBl3UFRJ3GIHnVTY=
22. Baptist World Aid Releases 11th Ethical Fashion Report (wisevoter.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHj40DZVAKzjXO2OHXcLF29qRuvOIprKlO7QkE-xvidRq0qbVQqqtrSPiqNkP1AFzz6AxUqNrfWXn9H5q2y41uvVAzumASS_Y1_4N9ctYCNswaO_44R4kOiP1ooWRaNcRkzZrYGTPBGaqWaVpH_JBRu7TyAOmKNYGiOZW3PGmu2NC00nVDJGSajHYZDo5rz0w==
23. Is it ethical to buy fast fashion? | Baptist World Aid Australia (baptistworldaid.org.au) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEI8EkOcaWVDcrJCfWQU8Cs-uAfMebUIbSEqa7GhTV-SXMzaluuEAUr5FKj5Ehos-czNYFXpNj9OqEu8da9tjcc24kSPg0gqtI8dXIrM4cdZjJ5rtCuQj3zOWXa63kpuwGSOqZZqsjrolKmzLN3PYGeU56n72C_PKLlyyOibY12d6Cqcw==
24. Baptist World Aid Ethical Fashion Report 2026 - The 11th Edition (substack.com) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHrSqAstRVTpOYpeZuAyFW9TDwSru64Oszs8cGS8O0Tfinaw0fKCOFeONbgrvD8XpOVsJUPzyDkQ9O8E-Ny_T9YRdeOom8uXRcRYqiF0LQvLANAr0DM2ZhC8YiNTxo_F5zBED5fdbLoBjRXAYuJYIAvR0nHYnS
25. Ethical Fashion Report 2026 - Tearfund New Zealand — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHeLad3kpFBsEoysLj2_nncNhUXq1yQePui1rDs9_AYcwDd7vOMI-uYf9U0Ac8KU0WC6ep7fEEqzEjvB4STW7M4zcHaq6NCasR1ZIh2pnU0KLW20adxCPW-jis75AjrvTJFSKbGyVcXq3C-A-q6_e9r7l4F0g==
26. Ethical Fashion Guide | Baptist World Aid Australia (baptistworldaid.org.au) — https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEdXDnqCXpdKESiDMKWgqXkrJntVHD5onb1URrcjBdXvmDdKQh8tAr2NksZ0OVb9vCHf9gGKlOmFhCxJSrZZdEyhh7BsEB2cMGXDYTIvseVtIZLjwerW0dbiBdhrWWm1CEAr6ZdaCuLZjer3bBd7H3tYrIQ4vM8fyfo
27. FAQs | Ethical Fashion Report | Baptist World Aid Australia (baptistworldaid.org.au) — https://baptistworldaid.org.au/faqs-ethical-fashion-report/
28. Ethical Fashion Report 2024 - Tasmanian Baptists (tasbaptists.org.au) — https://tasbaptists.org.au/ethical-fashion-report-2024/
29. Australia leads global fashion consumption: 10th Ethical Fashion Report - Fibre2Fashion (fibre2fashion.com) — https://www.fibre2fashion.com/news/apparel-news/australia-leads-global-fashion-consumption-10th-ethical-fashion-report-308182-newsdetails.htm
30. Australians buy more clothes than any other country - The Australia Institute (australiainstitute.org.au) — https://australiainstitute.org.au/post/australians-buy-more-clothes-than-any-other-country/
31. Baptist report highlights gap between fashion brands' commitments and workers' rights (christiandaily.com) — https://www.christiandaily.com/article/baptist-report-highlights-gap-between-fashion-brands-commitments-and-workers-rights/159844.htm
32. About the Report | Ethical Fashion Report | Baptist World Aid Australia (baptistworldaid.org.au) — https://baptistworldaid.org.au/about-the-report/
33. 2026 Baptist World Aid Ethical Fashion Report reveals stagnant industry progress (youtube.com) — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J3aY6W_pW3A
34. Australian fashion ethical practices stalling, Baptist World Aid report finds — Kyna Intel (kyna-intel.com) — https://kyna-intel.com/australian-fashion-ethical-practices-stalling-baptist-world-aid-report-finds/
35. Fast-fashion giant Shein outperforms several Australian retailers on ethics, report says | Fashion industry | The Guardian (theguardian.com) — https://www.theguardian.com/fashion/2026/oct/21/shein-ethical-fashion-report-myer-ghanda-windsor-smith
36. Shein Scores Higher Than Myer in Ethical Fashion Report: What It Means for Consumers - Shade Compass (shadecompass.com) — https://shadecompass.com/shein-scores-higher-than-myer-in-ethical-fashion-report-what-it-means-for-consumers/