A Senate Republican’s plan to prevent Social Security benefit cuts by tapping Treasury general revenue could add $190 trillion to the national debt over 75 years, according to a federal budget watchdog [2][3].
Senate Budget Committee Chairman Ron Johnson proposed the Stop Scaring Seniors Act on Nov. 18, directing Treasury general funds to cover Social Security retirement shortfalls once the trust fund runs out [1]. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimated the transfer would add $190 trillion in inflation-adjusted dollars — equal to 165% of GDP — to the national debt over 75 years [2].
‘Paying for Social Security out of the general fund would absolutely explode the national debt, costing a whopping 165% of GDP over 75 years before even considering the economic implications,’ CRFB President Maya MacGuineas said [2]. ‘This would bring us to a totally untenable level of borrowing that would almost certainly spark a crisis,’ she added [2].
CRFB Senior Vice President Marc Goldwein went further, arguing the proposal would authorize $800 trillion in borrowing over time while continuing to pay rising benefits to millionaire retirees [4]. Johnson disputed that framing. ‘I’m not proposing shutting down Social Security,’ he wrote, adding, ‘I’m proposing preventing benefits from ever being reduced’ [4].
A Senate Budget Committee report Johnson released the same day projected a Social Security program shortfall of roughly $511 billion by 2032 [3]. CRFB modeling found that funding benefits through general revenue could push interest rates up by about 2.6 percentage points, taking 10-year Treasury yields from 4% to 6.6% and 30-year mortgage rates from 6.3% to 8.9% [3].
The proposal arrives as the government approaches its borrowing limit. TD Securities projected the current $41.1 trillion debt ceiling will begin binding in January and that the government could run out of room by around September 2027 [3]. Johnson called on House members to introduce companion legislation [4].



